Dame Edna’s comments About Caitlyn Jenner might be impolite, however Are They fallacious?

Edna’s alter ego Barry Humphries do not have known as Jenner “mutilated” – but he’s right concerning the depressing upward push of “new puritanism”
 
Dame Edna Everage

Dame Edna Everage photo: Brian J. Ritchie/Hotsauce/REX

little or no in the way of tact is to be expected from Dame Edna Everage, the Aussie housewife celebrity, who once seen that intercourse “is essentially the most gorgeous factor that may happen between a fortunately married man and his secretary”.

Now Edna’s alter ego, Barry Humphries, has leapt to the defence of his friend Germaine Greer who has been under attack for claiming that transgender women like Caitlyn (previously Bruce) Jenner “can’t be girls”. “You’re a mutilated man, that’s all,” Humphries told the Telegraph. “Caitlyn Jenner – what a publicity-seeking rat-bag.”

Germaine Greer: the true enemy of women?

Germaine Greer has been closely criticised for claiming transgender girls “can’t be girls”.  photo: Rex

At 81, Humphries is previous the age of caring what somebody thinks and that can be a heady, freeing factor. but calling anyone who goes during the existence-changing anguish of a intercourse exchange “mutilated” is solely rude, frankly.

“It need to be absolute hell to feel you have been born in the mistaken physique. Let’s be happy that the stigma is being lifted”

Humphries is spot on, however, in regards to the “new puritanism”. Witness the usual suspects, who immediately called on the performer to apologise for his blasphemy towards the secular religion of “variety and inclusion”.

the fact is most girls consider Germaine Greer. that you may’t live for sixty five years in the physique of a person, as Bruce Jenner did, develop a pair of boobs, put on a bit of lippy and and declare that overnight – ta-da! – you’re female. Being a girl is made from a billion small things since you had been born a girl; it’s more about feelings and experiences than it’s about breasts and genitalia.

Olympic gold medal-winning athlete formerly known as Bruce Jenner features on the front cover of Vanity Fair with the headline "Call me Caitlyn"

Caitlyn Jenner on the cover of vanity truthful journal.  photograph: photo: vainness honest/Anne Leibovitz

It should be absolute hell to really feel you have been born in the improper body. Let’s be satisfied that the stigma is being lifted.

nevertheless it’s not proper that the rest of us must be cowed into agreeing with one thing we instinctively have doubts about just because we’re fearful of falling foul of the Tolerance Police. (notice how grossly illiberal are individuals who preach tolerance to us!)

“that you can’t describe the world as it’s to any extent further,” says Barry Humphries. And that’s not simply sad, it’s bad.

 

Telegraph Columnists: day-to-day opinion, editorials and columns from our big name writers

(46)